When I was in high school, I gave piano lessons to a lot of kids (maybe 10?). It was great to have such a relatively easy way to earn college money (I can’t remember what I charged, but it was significantly more than I could have made working at a fast food place).
In the past year, things have come full-circle as I’m now back to 10 piano students again. I have mixed feelings about it – about half the kids work pretty hard at it and do well, but then there’s the other half.
Their moms are always enthusiastic when they first call: “Kailee is so excited to start piano! She plays around a lot on the piano at home, and – (here she’ll conspiratorially lower her voice) she’s really pretty good!”
Ah. The shot across the deck: little prodigy will soon be arriving. I’m still waiting for the mom who’ll say: “Mariah has no sense of rhythm and really doesn’t plan to practice much, but I think the effort at a discipline-requiring activity will be good for her.” I think I could appreciate that honesty.
One little piano girl comes every other week. Her mom set it up that way, she said, because the girl had so much homework and she needed time to prepare. The girl is in second grade. Frequently the mom calls and cancels, resulting in lessons 3 weeks apart. She recently said, “I’d like her to progress as quickly as possible.” Yeah, that’d be nice, wouldn’t it?
Another mom is so excited because her daughter “plays the piano not because she has to, but because it’s fun! That’s what I want to see, her having fun!” This conversation begins to make me nervous, because unless this girl is different from 99% of the population, piano will (sooner rather than later) become not-just-fun. Like anything else worth doing, it requires effort. Hey, I’d like to eat cookies all day and skip exercise too, but I prefer not to weigh 200 pounds. What can I say? It’s fun to be able to play the piano, but it requires quite a bit of effort to get there. Sadly, that effort is not always fun. But (and this is a point that’s really difficult for many of today’s kids and parents) it is worthwhile to keep at it.
I begin a new piano student today (that is, if she can walk across the street through the expected 12 inches of snow). I hope your day will be lovely and worthwhile as well
.















